09/22/2026
The St. Johns County Sheriff's Office has arrested and charged Jake Matthew (34) with multiple felony offenses, including: Aggravated Animal Cruelty, Possession of a Fi***rm by a Convicted Felon, False Report to Law Enforcement, Unlawful Disposal of a Dead Animal, and Using an Animal to Fight or Bait.
On August 25, 2026, deputies responded to the 3000 block of Ninth Street in Elkton after receiving multiple calls reporting gunshots near Matthew's home. Deputies did not locate anything suspicious at the time. The next day, deputies returned to the area after the remains of a decapitated adult female dog were discovered at a vacant lot on Tenth Street.
SJSO Property Crimes Detectives executed a search warrant at Matthew's home, locating additional mutilated dog remains, a gun cleaning kit with gun oil, a box used to store pistols, several other items and accessories. No fi***rm was recovered. Matthew is a convicted felon and is not allowed to possess any fi****ms.
On September 2, 2026, detectives executed a second search warrant, locating several 9MM shell casings in the backyard near the area where the dog's remains had been found, along with a fired bullet from a tree truck. Detectives also located two dead cats on the property and seized two adult male dogs, eight puppies, and two piglets.
A necropsy conducted by the UF College of Veterinary Medicine determined the dog, identified as Matthew's adult female dog, 'Daisy', was shot several times at close range.
Based on the investigation, detectives believe Matthew killed Daisy in the backyard using a 9MM handgun.
Matthew was arrested on September 17, 2026, and is currently in custody at the St. Johns County Jail on $45,750 bond.