09/09/2026
🏠 Floridians paid nearly $3 billion less for home and auto insurance last year than the year before.
THE BOTTOM LINE: For years, this looked like a street where the restaurants kept closing — fewer places open, and the ones left could charge whatever they wanted. What changed is that new operators started opening again. Twenty companies began writing coverage in Florida, bringing more than $850 million in new capital, and when there are more places to buy, prices stop climbing on their own.
THE NUMBERS 📊
1️⃣ HOMEOWNERS: $1.29 billion less paid in 2025 than 2024 — a 7% decline.
2️⃣ AUTO: $1.7 billion less, a 5% decline, with average rates down 4.1%.
3️⃣ RATE CHANGE: The average homeowners rate change was under 1%. In 2023, it was 9.6%.
4️⃣ DIVIDENDS: Insurers returned $211 million to policyholders — 43% more than the prior year and more than double 2023.
THE ONE THAT MATTERS MOST FOR BROWARD 📍
Citizens Property Insurance — the state-backed insurer of last resort — held 15% of Florida's total insured value in 2023. By 202,5 that was down to 3%. Citizens is not supposed to be anyone's first choice. When its share shrinks, it means private carriers are willing to write the risk again, and that is the single clearest sign the market is functioning.
WHERE THIS COMES FROM, HONESTLY
The American Property Casualty Insurance Association — the insurance industry's own trade group — commissioned the study, and it credits Florida's legal-system-abuse reforms for the turnaround. An industry-funded study arguing that laws favoring the industry worked is worth reading with that in mind. The direction of travel matches what I'm seeing at closings; treat the causation claim as their argument, not settled fact.
And a renewal quote is still the only number that tells you what YOUR house costs to insure. Statewide averages don't pay your bill.
Has your renewal actually come down this year, or are you still fighting it? I want to hear real numbers.
Source — Florida Realtors, Sept. 8, 2026: https://www.floridarealtors.org/news-media/news-articles/2026/09/florida-home-auto-premiums-drop-nearly-3-billion
Chuck Bonfiglio · 2026 President, Florida Realtors
Broker/Owner, AAA Realty Group · 954-998-6683