The Cream City Real Estate Company

The Cream City Real Estate Company Serving home buyers and sellers in the Greater Milwaukee/Southeast Wisconsin area since 2002. So if you are looking for a fresh approach, give us a call.

From our historic home office in Bay View, we sell homes all over the Milwaukee metro area and beyond. We are not just about the sale—we focus on becoming advocates to our clients so that they can make informed decisions through the buying or selling process. Matching the right buyer with the right home is our criterion for success. Our agents themselves span the different phases of home ownership

, so we know from personal experience how housing needs change: from that exciting first home, to that move-up dream house, through downsizing from the empty nest, to moving an aging parent to a new social environment in senior living. As agents we work collaboratively to bring an even greater depth of experience to each transaction. It makes our work fun for us, and our clients sense that energy we bring to the job. Our loyal customers have become trusted friends and raving fans, generously referring others to our company. We’d love to put our experience to work for you.

08/29/2026

OPEN HOUSES this weekend!!!

Saturday, August 29: 1 ~ 2:30pm
Sunday, August 30: 11am ~ 12:30pm

Prime Bay View location!!! 2501 S Lenox St - $319,900

2 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, + a bonus room! Brand new roof!!! Call or text today! 414-418-1498

✨ New Listing✨📌3153 S. Pennsylvania Ave. - $425,000.Welcome home! Located in the Fernwood neighborhood of Bay View, this...
08/28/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📌3153 S. Pennsylvania Ave. - $425,000.

Welcome home! Located in the Fernwood neighborhood of Bay View, this updated colonial is a short walk to the farmer's market and amazing restaurants. This home offers an updated kitchen and bathrooms. The quality shows in the details, hardwood floors throughout, and tasteful decor in every room. Upstairs are all the bedrooms and a full bathroom tucked away in the tree tops. A rec room in the basement allows for extra space. An updated patio door makes for easy access to the backyard and garage. Fenced in for your furry friends. a 1.5 car garage has extra space for a workshop. Call today!

More information and photos online at CreamCityRealEstate.com

✨ New Listing✨📌2329 N. 115th St. - $299,900.Welcome to Wauwatosa. This quality built ranch home features an open layout ...
08/28/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📌2329 N. 115th St. - $299,900.

Welcome to Wauwatosa. This quality built ranch home features an open layout and original hard wood floors in the bedrooms. Updated kitchen with a large dinette is full of sunlight! Pride of owner ship throughout. The 1.5 baths have been updated. Neutral decor. Walk to all the local schools 3 blocks away! Fenced in yard with nice patio and shed. Call today! Room sizes are estimated

More information at CreamCityRealEstate.com

Thanks, Alexander, for your feedback!💚🏡💚Lindsey is an excellent Realtor and helped me find the perfect house. I am extre...
08/28/2026

Thanks, Alexander, for your feedback!
💚🏡💚

Lindsey is an excellent Realtor and helped me find the perfect house. I am extremely happy with how everything turned out, and Lindsey was there every step of the way making sure I got my perfect house. I could not imagine a better Realtor.

08/26/2026

OPEN HOUSES this weekend!

Saturday, August 29: 1 ~ 2:30pm
Sunday, August 30: 11am ~ 12:30pm

Prime Bay View location!!! 2501 S Lenox St - $319,900

2 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, + a bonus room! Brand new roof!!! Call or text today! 414-418-1498

OPEN HOUSE this afternoon Saturday, August 22nd from 12:00-1:30pmCome join me after the Farmers Market!✨ New Listing✨📌25...
08/20/2026

OPEN HOUSE this afternoon Saturday, August 22nd from 12:00-1:30pm

Come join me after the Farmers Market!

✨ New Listing✨
📌2501 S Lenox St - $319,900

Here's your ideal spot, right in the center of Bay View! This 1890 Puddler's Cottage is bright and updated, with tall ceilings, hardwood floors, and two full baths. The main level has a spacious open concept living and dining area, kitchen, bedroom and bath. The amazing lower level has exposed Cream City brick walls, and features a large primary bedroom, bath, and large office/den area. More recent updates include engineered hardwood flooring, back deck and 2026 roof. Prime location for walking to movies at the Avalon, the library, shops, restaurants and work-out spaces in the neighborhood!

📸More information is online at CreamCityRealEstate.com

✨ New Listing✨📌3948 E. Underwood Ave. - $285,000.Welcome home to this brick Mid Century ranch located just off the shore...
08/19/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📌3948 E. Underwood Ave. - $285,000.

Welcome home to this brick Mid Century ranch located just off the shores of Lake Michigan. This solid, quality built home is a perfect place to live. Three bedrooms and 1.5 bathrooms. Hard wood floors under carpet (per seller). Large sunny eat in kitchen with bright corner windows that overlook the backyard. Downstairs you will find a large rec room perfect for hosting Packer parties and the holidays with a bonus half bath! Included items are the electric fireplace, Bose surround sound system, TVs and recessed mini fridge. Outside there is a patio for dining alfresco and a fenced in yard with a 1.5 car garage.

📸More information is online at CreamCityRealEstate.com.

08/18/2026

Live by the Lake! All brick Mid Century Ranch in Cudahy! 3 bedrooms 1.5 baths and an amazing vintage Rec room. $285,000. Call or text today! 414-405-7435

✨ New Listing✨📌3745 S. Whitnall Ave. - $305,000.Maintained with care and full of warmth, this 4 bed, 1 bath bungalow sit...
08/15/2026

✨ New Listing✨
📌3745 S. Whitnall Ave. - $305,000.

Maintained with care and full of warmth, this 4 bed, 1 bath bungalow sits in the ever-growing and friendly Town of Lake. Spacious bedrooms offer room to stretch, while the updated kitchen w/ stainless steel appliances is a true highlight. Downstairs, the partially finished basement offers abundant storage plus bonus potential, ready to become any space you need. Out back, unwind in your own private yard, featuring a charming gazebo perfect for lazy afternoons, a garden spot to grow veggies or flowers, and lots of room for kids or pets to run free. A 2-car garage plus additional off-street parking offer no shortage of space for vehicles, guests, or storage. Room to spread out in a neighborhood full of welcoming faces make this home ready for its next chapter!

More information online at CreamCityRealEstate.com

Thanks, Halle, for your feedback!💚🏡💚"My partner and I had the best first time home buying experience with Shelly from Cr...
08/07/2026

Thanks, Halle, for your feedback!
💚🏡💚

"My partner and I had the best first time home buying experience with Shelly from Cream City! Shelly is so knowledgeable and really took the time to help us learn all about Bay View houses. We felt confident that her goal was to help us find our perfect home. Her honesty and support during the process helped us feel secure in every step of making the biggest purchase of our lives. We would highly recommend her to any and all of our friends and family looking to buy! If we could do it over again, we would choose Shelly in a heartbeat."

Address

3474 S Pennsylvania Avenue
Milwaukee, WI
53207

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Cream City Real Estate Company posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Practice

Send a message to The Cream City Real Estate Company:

Shortcuts

Share

Category