18/05/2026
🏡🏠
Selling immoveable property in foreclosure proceedings 👇
The Mpumalanga Division of the High Court of South Africa recently delivered an important judgment on compliance with Uniform Rule 46A in applications to declare residential properties specially executable.
In The Standard Bank of South Africa Ltd v Gutu and related matters, the Court consolidated three unopposed foreclosure matters where banks and finance institutions sought default judgment, ex*****on orders, and reserve prices against residential properties.
The Court emphasised that Rule 46A exists to ensure proper judicial oversight before a person’s home is sold in ex*****on, and that courts cannot simply “rubber stamp” unopposed applications.
A major issue in all three matters was the quality and reliability of the valuation evidence placed before the Court. The Court criticised:
• desktop and “drive-by” valuations;
• inadequate or absent inspections;
• contradictory valuation affidavits;
• improper commissioning of affidavits;
• electronic signatures and incomplete attestations; and
• repeated filing of defective valuation material.
The Court held that without proper sworn valuation evidence, it could not reliably determine market value or set a fair reserve price as required by Rule 46A.
All three applications were removed from the roll, with leave granted to file fresh compliant valuations. Importantly, the Court also directed that wasted costs caused by the defective applications may not be debited to the consumers’ loan accounts.
The judgment serves as a reminder that even in unopposed foreclosure matters, strict compliance with Rule 46A remains essential and that valuation evidence must be properly prepared, sworn to, and reliable before ex*****on against a home will be authorised.
FLYNOTES: CIVIL PROCEDURE – Ex*****on – Residential property – Valuations – Three unopposed applications for ex*****on against homes consolidated – Applicants sought default judgment and reserve prices under Rule 46A – Court emphasised constitutional purpose of Rule 46A, requiri...