31/08/2026
A premium on being mentally conscious — or on being alive?
During argument before the Constitutional Court, Acting Justice Ngcukaitobi put it to counsel that the government's argument was "premised on some sort of special recognition of mental awareness, rather than the fact of being alive".
Echoing the second amicus, he suggested this was "reflective of the embedded discrimination against mentally disabled persons, because there's some premium placed on this idea of being mentally conscious, as opposed to putting a premium on the idea of being alive".
The exchange arose during oral argument in a medical negligence appeal before the Constitutional Court and does not represent a final finding of the Court.
Footage reproduced with the kind permission of the Constitutional Court of South Africa.
acdsattorneys.co.za
This post is general information, not legal advice.