29/10/2026
What if a manager swears at a subordinate and physically stops her from walking away – is dismissal fair?
In this episode of our “What if” series, we unpack a recent Labour Court judgment in which an operations manager at DSV Solutions was dismissed for swearing at a subordinate and placing his hands on her shoulders to stop her leaving an argument. No injury was caused, and both employees had sworn, yet the Court upheld the dismissal as fair.
We look at the four arguments the Court rejected; provocation, the absence of a trust-breakdown witness, the lack of a zero-tolerance policy, and inconsistency and set out five practical lessons for employers on physical contact, provocation, proving trust breakdown, setting standards in the disciplinary code, and charging even-handedly.
WATCH THE VIDEO
https://youtube.com/watch?v=AKUtDWzrsic&utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=whatif+swear+manager
LISTEN TO PODCAST
https://open.spotify.com/episode/0PK2QGOTJiPryWSFOWdurq?si=u3YPGAWhSYG2iRrY4xOkKg