06/23/2026
California lemon law tier list: luxury car manufacturers ranked by how they actually treat you when you bring a claim.
Some settle when the case is strong. Others fight every one, regardless of the facts. After years of filing against every major luxury manufacturer, the patterns are consistent.
What separates a good manufacturer from a bad one on this list: how they respond to repeat repair visits for the same defect, whether they use arbitration clauses to keep claims out of court, how close early settlement offers come to what the case is worth, and whether known defects are acknowledged or denied at every turn.
The full ranking goes from F tier — manufacturers that take cases to trial and redirect blame to the owner — up to S tier, where a solid case gets a fair outcome.
If your luxury vehicle has made repeat trips to the dealer for the same problem, California lemon law may apply.
Attorney Advertisement. Past results are not indicative of future results, which vary. Legal services by Sina Rez Law, APC, Woodland Hills, CA.