06/05/2026
Mark was ticketed on 7th Avenue after an officer testified he pulled up next to Mark's car at a red light and clearly saw him holding a black, rectangular device against his cheek. Facing five points for a mobile phone violation and severe insurance hikes, Mark hired a lawyer for his TVB hearing.
His attorney introduced a defense of "Mistaken Object Identity." Using timestamped interior dashcam footage and the physical item itself, the lawyer presented exactly what Mark was holding that morning.
The attorney argued that the officer’s visual observation was understandable—Mark was indeed holding a black device to his face. However, Mark was running late for a meeting and was actively using a compact, rectangular electric travel shaver. The device shared the exact matte-black profile of a modern smartphone but lacked any communication capabilities. Furthermore, vehicle Bluetooth logs proved Mark's actual phone was securely zipped inside his briefcase in the backseat the entire time.
The judge agreed that while the action was unusual, it did not meet the strict statutory definition of holding a mobile telephone under New York traffic law. Because the officer could not prove the device was a phone, the ticket was dismissed entirely, and Mark kept a clean driving record.
🚗⚖️ ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
https://nytrafficticketlawyers.com