10/14/2026
A bicyclist was killed in a collision with an FDNY ambulance on Staten Island, raising an important legal question: what rights do pedestrians and cyclists have when they are struck by an ambulance or other emergency vehicle in New York?
Emergency vehicles are not automatically immune from liability. The legal standard can depend on whether the ambulance was actually responding to an emergency at the time of the crash and what the driver was doing immediately before the collision.
In this case, authorities reported that the ambulance was not transporting a patient and was not responding to an emergency when the crash occurred.
When an ambulance is not engaged in an emergency operation, ordinary negligence principles may apply. Investigators may examine issues such as speed, visibility, right-of-way, turning movements, whether the driver maintained a proper lookout, and whether the collision could have been avoided.
Even if a cyclist or pedestrian may also have violated a traffic rule, that does not necessarily end the liability analysis. New York follows comparative negligence rules, which means more than one party can potentially share responsibility for an accident.
When an FDNY or other municipal vehicle is involved, injured victims and surviving family members may also face special notice requirements and shorter deadlines for bringing a claim against the City.
Cases involving ambulances and other emergency vehicles can be legally complex and require careful investigation of dispatch records, surveillance footage, GPS data, witness statements, vehicle information and roadway evidence.
Our attorneys represent pedestrians, cyclists and families in serious injury and wrongful death cases throughout New York.