10/21/2022
A reporter posted a question on a private message board about refinancing and/or consolidating federal student loans. The first part of the question was "What does it mean to refinance a student loan?" Here is my response:
That first question is the right starting point. Before opening the door to this conversation you have to lay a foundation and define some terms. Since 95% of all student loans are federal, in most cases when this question comes up it means that someone with federal student loans is considering borrowing private money to pay off federal student loans. While it is possible for that arrangement to turn out well, on the front end that is almost never a good idea. IF you are getting a considerably lower interest rate, and IF you can be 100% certain of always being able to make all of the payments on time, for however many years that may turn out to be, THEN it's the right move. But how many of us can ever be certain of making payments for the next few years, much less then next 20, 30, or more? It's simply not realistic. From a gambler's perspective, it's a bad bet.
With federal student loans there is almost always a back door out of a bad situation. Not so with private loans (whether they were always private, or refinanced, as contemplated here).
Relevant maxim #1: Friends don't let friends take out private student loans.
Now, if what you're really talking about is consolidating federal loans, that's another story. In the federal system "consolidation" is really exactly the same thing as refinancing, with one huge distinction. Rather than borrowing private money, you're taking out a new loan from the Dept of Education to pay off existing federal loans. That's not always necessary, but (A) in most cases it is the fastest way to get out of default, and (B) in many cases it's the first step toward getting into a better (i.e. "lower") payment plan.
So refinancing a federal loan using private money is almost always a mistake. But depending on circumstances, "consolidation" (to use the confusing official federal term) can be a life-saver, a wise move, or both.
Another point in favor of federal consolidation is that there is no credit check or approval requirement. If consolidation is an option for you, then you just fill out the form and you're done. (Not everyone can consolidate, but most can, especially right now, while "The Pause" is still in effect.) Conversely, a private loan is exactly that. Private. Not only will you have to qualify credit-wise, but they will do their damnedest to get you to persuade someone to co-sign the loan with you.
Relevant Maxim #2: With the possible exception of your spouse, don't ever co-sign anything for anyone. Never. Just don't.
I hope this helps. Let me know if you have any other thoughts or questions.
Bruce Ralston
Memphis Consumer Lawyer