06/03/2026
WHEN IS GOING TO TRIAL THE RIGHT DECISION?
One of the most important decisions a person facing criminal charges will make is whether to accept a plea agreement or proceed to trial.
Many people assume that every criminal case should settle. Others believe every case should go to trial. The truth is that neither approach is automatically right.
Every case must be evaluated on its own facts.
Going to trial may be the right decision when:
1.The evidence is weak or questionable
2. Witnesses are inconsistent or lack credibility
3. There are significant constitutional issues
4. The prosecution cannot prove every element of the offense
5. The plea offer is unreasonable
6. The potential consequences of pleading guilty are severe
7. The accused maintains innocence and wishes to exercise the right to trial
A trial is not simply about telling your side of the story. It is about requiring the Commonwealth to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
At the same time, trials involve risk. No honest attorney can guarantee a result. The decision whether to proceed to trial should be based upon a careful review of the evidence, legal issues, potential defenses, and possible outcomes.
Whether you are facing charges involving DUI, ma*****na DUI, drug possession, aggravated assault, homicide, robbery, theft, fi****ms offenses, sexual assault allegations, or other criminal offenses, understanding your options is critical.
The Law Office of John B. Pike represents clients throughout Luzerne, Lackawanna, Wyoming, Columbia, Carbon, Bradford, Susquehanna, and Wayne Counties, including Wilkes-Barre, Kingston, Pittston, Hazleton, Scranton, Bloomsburg, Towanda, Montrose, Honesdale, and surrounding communities.
If you are facing criminal charges, make sure you understand all available options before deciding whether to plead guilty or proceed to trial.