10/07/2026
Another jury verdict today. Another jury asking: “Where was the insurance?”
During jury selection (voir dire), potential jurors repeatedly talked about insurance companies and their own experiences after a wreck. We had to bite our tongues. We couldn’t tell them what had happened in this very case.
And it was maddening.
Long before trial, State Farm admitted liability. State Farm acknowledged the total value of our client’s Jeep, which was destroyed in the wreck. State Farm put that value in a letter to our client.
Then State Farm refused to pay when their insured changed his mind about who was at fault in the wreck.
Did the jury hear those facts? No.
Did the jury hear the name State Farm? Not once. Did the jury get to see the letter from State Farm? Nope.
After the verdict, the questions came again: “Was there no insurance? Where was the insurance?”
Of course there was insurance! The jury simply wasn’t allowed to hear about it.
Jurors bring common sense and real-world experience into the courtroom. They know insurance is part of everyday life. Yet in cases like this, we ask them to decide the case with that part of the story hidden from view.
Justice was served today. But it is unfair to keep juries in the dark.