07/02/2020
PPP Update:
Pending President Trump's signature, Congress has passed an extension for the time to apply for the PPP loans until August 8, 2020. If you missed yesterday's original PPP application deadline, fear not, you can still apply. That is the good news...........
The frustrating news is something I have known about for months and kept silent about because frankly nobody needs to hear more political nonsense. But after reading the Congressional presser regarding the extension I have to say something that you all should all at least consider. First of all, while this is a Democratic majority Congress, I blame every member regardless of party for either the games played with or the accounting ignorance of the PPP program. The Congressional program has been inefficient in its roll out, irresponsible in its use of banks as the point entities for approval and distribution of funds and agreement to pay them an origination fee, disjointed and confusingly inconsistent with the rules of use of the loans once received and frankly derelict in their duty to properly account for the $660 billion in taxpayer money to fund the program.
Inefficiency of funds delivery to small businesses and frustrating changes to the rules and regulations for approval and use have been discussed before, so I will not get into that right now. What frustrates me is two-fold: (1) Congressional misappropriation and just bad math, and; (2) that Congress did not use the resources it had and chose to pay banks, using taxpayer money, origination fees for the PPP loans. Regarding the first issue, Nancy Pelosi went on the podium about a month ago and praised the facts that at that time 3 million of the 30+ million small businesses were saved by the PPP. That number of 30+ million seemed high so I took the next 6 minutes to research the IRS numbers and found out that there are 30+ million small businesses registered, but 8 million of those were non-functioning shell companies with no assets, employees and/or business activities. So, the budget for 30 million small businesses was off by about 25%, or about $165 billion. Anyone in the private sector would have been fired on the spot for such an egregious accounting error. Today, with the passage by the House of the extension, Pelosi took credit on behalf of the House for extending the assistance to small businesses as if they did us a favor. Well, sort of, because what is left over is not $165 billion, but $130 billion. Ironically, per my calculations the assumed 5% origination fee average (since most loans were under $350,000 and such loans earned a 5% fee for banks) equals approximately $35 billion. So, in short, Congress allocated $660 billion for a budget that rightfully should have equaled $495 billion. When the banks bill came to $35 billion (which should have never been paid out of the PPP fund for small business, but looks like it was. And by the way, the banks are in no way to blame for this gaff) it appears that the bank fees were paid with the over-inflated original budget and the remaining $130 billion is now marketed by Congress to be due to the hard work and caring of Congress. I only name Nancy Pelosi because she is the Majority Leader and she is the one on the podium, but all of Congress is to blame for every penny of waste and political use because nobody there was either competent or ethical enough to raise the issue.
If we had a Congress that could or would do math with facts and figures that they had at their fingertips and that I retrieved in six minutes, what benefits could We the People have gleaned from an additional $200 billion in misappropriated funds and bank fees? Asking for 325 million friends.