David M. Seiter, Attorney at Law

David M. Seiter, Attorney at Law Since 1998, Attorney David M. Seiter, has been practicing law in Indiana. David was admitted to practice law throughout the state of Indiana in 1998.

He is a former judicial officer committed to resolving legal issues throughout central Indiana. As a general practice lawyer, he has experience in both criminal and civil law. David practiced law for over 14 years and built a successful private practice before serving as a judicial officer in Marion County, Indiana for 3.5 years. As a judicial officer, David was assigned to the Arrestee Processing

Center (APC) and major felony drug court where he focused his efforts on problem solving and reducing recidivism through offender education efforts. Returning to private practice in October, 2016, David expects to incorporate the lessons he learned from the judiciary in assessing the strengths and weaknesses of his client’s cases. David has major felony trial experience and appellate advocacy experience. While many lawyers will spend an entire career and never have the opportunity to argue before the Indiana Supreme Court, David has done so three (3) times. Those decisions have helped shape Indiana law in the areas of Operating a Vehicle while Intoxicated and Habitual Traffic Violator offenses. In 2013, David retired as a field grade officer in the U.S. Army Reserves after serving for 25 years. Originally enlisting as a private out of high school in 1988 David was later commissioned through ROTC as a Second Lieutenant in the Military Police and completed the U.S. Army’s Airborne school. David served as a commander of the 384th MP HHC in Fort Wayne, IN, before transferring to the Judge Advocates General (JAG) Corps in 2000 where he served the remainder of his Army career as a military lawyer. In 2003, David deployed to Iraq as a JAG officer with the 800th Military Police Battalion in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom. He was assigned to the Coalition Provisional Authority (CPA) in the Iraqi Ministry of Justice where he served as the “ombudsman” for juvenile and female detainees. David earned the Bronze Star during his deployment for a variety of accomplishments including 1) obtaining a confession from an Iraqi detainee concerning placement of over 500 anti-tank and personnel mines, 2) successfully negotiating the peaceful displacement of over 1500 squatters from Iraqi government lands, 3) exhibiting the proper care and control over Iraqi detainees and 4) organizing charitable events to better the Iraqi people. Despite being in the middle of a war zone, David made international news when he established an Arabic library in the Al-Karhk Juvenile detention facility and held a charitable event called “Operation Touchdown” in which two Baghdad orphanages were introduced to the sport of American Football with the assistance of the Indianapolis Colts and New Orleans Saints franchises. David later renewed the Operation Touchdown theme in 2006 and 2010 raising money for the United Services Organization (USO) and Wounded Warrior Project, respectively. David is also an adjunct professor at Indiana University-Purdue University-Indianapolis (IUPUI) where he teaches “Substantive Criminal Law” for the School of Public and Environmental Affairs. Additionally, David has presented classes to fellow members of the Indiana bar and judges on the “Military Aspects of Divorce in Indiana” and the “Servicemember’s Civil Relief Act”. In the military, David instructed multiple military units on topics such as “Federal Ethics”, “Code of Conduct”, “Law of War”, “Rules of Engagement” and “General Orders in a Combat Theater”. David is a credited contributor in two published books written by Dr. Erin Albert: “Indianapolis: A Young Professional’s Guide” (2010) and “Multipationals: The Changing World of Work and How to Create Your Best Career Portfolio” (2015). In 2007, Dave was a finalist for Junior Achievement’s “Indy’s Best and Brightest- Law Category”. Although born and raised in Michigan, David has lived in the Indianapolis area since 1994. He graduated with an undergraduate degree in Criminal Justice with minors in Political Science and Military Science from Western Michigan University in 1992. After completing his initial military obligations, David moved to Indianapolis to obtain his law degree at Indiana University – McKinney School of Law in Indianapolis, Indiana. David graduated from law school in 1998 and was admitted to the Indiana State Bar after passing the Bar Exam that same year. David currently lives in Indianapolis, Indiana with his wife, three children and a variety of pets. He enjoys spending time with his family, attending sporting events, and volunteering for charitable, military, and political organizations. Since 2008, David has managed operations for the Indianapolis Tornados minor league football team. David is an active member of the Indiana State Bar and his local community. If you would like to contact David about legal services, you may reach him at [email protected] or by calling Riley Cate, LLC at 317-588-2866.

04/29/2026

Generally, candidates should not use official Army (or other military) logos on campaign signs.

Here’s how the rules break down:

🚫 Military logos / insignia
• Official Army logos, seals, and insignia are protected trademarks of the U.S. Department of Defense.
• They cannot be used by private individuals (including political campaigns) in advertising or promotional materials without permission.
• The key concern is avoiding any appearance that the military endorses a candidate. 

👉 That includes campaign signs—those are considered campaign advertising.

⚠️ Specific rule for candidates
• Candidates can say they served in the Army, Navy, etc.
• But they cannot use military logos or branding in a way that suggests endorsement.

If you have any questions about something you receive demanding fees, call me.   317 588-2866.
03/02/2026

If you have any questions about something you receive demanding fees, call me. 317 588-2866.

NEW TOLL SCAM : I've had multiple send me this today. The scammer is sending it as an attachment in a text message. This is a SCAM!!

There is no Judge John Smith in Marion Superior Court. Do not scan the QR code-- it could take you to a malicious website and steal your personal information.

This scam takes it a level up by offering up a case # that has the appropriate prefix of 49 (for Marion County) in it, which could lead some people to think this is real. It is not!

Do not fall for this.

By the way, I searched this case number and it doesn't even exist.

Let me know if you received this!!

01/20/2026

A reminder to never take your legal advice from random people on Facebook: I saw a recent series of messages indicating that ICE is not law enforcement and therefore you cannot be arrested for resisting them. This is FALSE!

ICE (U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement) is considered a federal law enforcement

• ICE is part of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS).
• Its officers and agents have law enforcement authority, including the power to:
• Investigate crimes
• Make arrests
• Carry fi****ms
• Execute search and arrest warrants

ICE has two main operational branches:
1. Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) – focuses on immigration enforcement, detention, and deportation.
2. Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) – conducts criminal investigations involving things like human trafficking, drug smuggling, cybercrime, and financial crimes.

While ICE is often discussed in the context of immigration, its personnel are sworn federal law enforcement officers, similar in legal status (though not mission) to agencies like the FBI or DEA.

Therefore, protestors who resist ICE are putting themselves at risk of criminal charges.

Please take a moment to read
12/08/2025

Please take a moment to read

HOLIDAY SCAM ALERT

The Marion County Sheriff’s Office (MCSO) has experienced a sharp increase of reports of scam attacks this holiday season. While these schemes occur year-round, recent reports show a growing number of community members subject to increasingly sophisticated tactics. The MCSO warns that callers are impersonating law enforcement and claiming that potential victims have failed to appear for jury duty, have an outstanding criminal warrant, or owe immediate payment to avoid arrest. In some cases, victims are being instructed to appear in person at the Community Justice Campus as part of the deception. These telephone calls have escalated in frequency ahead of the holidays.

“These fraudulent calls are highly convincing,” said Executive Officer Kelvis Williams. “Scammers are using official-sounding language, spoofed telephone numbers, and intimidation tactics to pressure people into paying immediately. They are even using real deputy’s names. It is critical that the public know that law enforcement will NEVER demand payment over the telephone, and certainly will not demand payment in the form of gift cards or cryptocurrency nor through payment apps and wire transfers.”

How to verify the legitimacy of telephone calls:

The Sheriff’s Office does contact individuals – generally through certified mail or in-person service – regarding tax warrants. If you owe a payment for a tax warrant, you can verify the legitimacy by calling the MCSO Judicial Enforcement Division at 317-327-2448.
If a telephone caller claims any of the following, it is highly likely to be a scam:
• You failed to appear for jury duty
• You have a criminal arrest warrant
• You must pay a bond or a fine immediately
• A loved one has been arrested

Citizens should independently verify information before responding or engaging with the telephone caller.

Helpful verification links will be pasted in the comments.

Residents are encouraged to never share their personal information over the telephone or online unless they have verified the source. If you are ever unsure of whether the call you are getting is legitimate, you may reach out to the Marion County Sheriff’s Office for clarification.

# # #

Do you know someone whose driving privileges were suspended for life under Indiana Code 9-30-10-14.1?   They may now qua...
11/18/2025

Do you know someone whose driving privileges were suspended for life under Indiana Code 9-30-10-14.1? They may now qualify for rescission of the lifetime suspension. Don’t simply ask for Specialized driving privileges. Get your full license back. Call me at 317-588-2866 for a free consultation.

09/18/2025

In 1995 McArthur Wheeler robbed two banks with lemon juice on his face believing it would make him invisible to security cameras like invisible ink. He even smiled at the cameras and was caught within hours. His case inspired the research that led to the discovery of the Dunning Kruger effect.

In the spring of 1995, McArthur Wheeler walked into two banks in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, to carry out robberies. What made the case unusual wasn’t the crime itself but his belief in a bizarre “getaway tactic.” Wheeler had smeared lemon juice on his face, convinced it would render him invisible to security cameras. His reasoning came from the fact that lemon juice can be used as invisible ink, only becoming visible when exposed to heat. He mistakenly assumed the same principle applied to surveillance footage.

When police reviewed the tapes, Wheeler was easily identifiable, he even looked directly at the cameras and smiled, confident in his “invisibility.” Within hours, police arrested him. Shocked at being caught, Wheeler reportedly exclaimed: “But I wore the juice!”

The case caught the attention of psychologists David Dunning and Justin Kruger. They were fascinated not just by Wheeler’s flawed logic but by his absolute confidence in it. This became the foundation for their groundbreaking research into cognitive bias. In 1999, they published their study on what is now called the Dunning-Kruger effect: a psychological phenomenon where people with limited knowledge or skill greatly overestimate their competence.

Wheeler’s lemon-juice blunder has since become a textbook example of this effect. It demonstrates how ignorance isn’t simply the absence of knowledge, it can foster misplaced certainty. His case, though humorous in hindsight, underscores a universal human flaw: the less we know, the more likely we are to overestimate our abilities.

05/02/2025

SCAM ALERT: A good friend called because he found out his son was in a car accident and allegedly arrested for OVWI. The caller indicated that he had been appointed an attorney and that a bond in the amount of $5000 cash needed to be posted. I checked mycase.in.gov and learned that no charges had been filed. This made me question how an attorney was appointed since public defenders are appointed at the initial hearing AFTER charges are filed. I then looked at the jail inmate list for Marion and surrounding counties and didn't find his name. I called my friend back to ask why he thought his son was in trouble. He said that he talked to his son when his son called him from the jail. I asked him to call his son's cell phone and sure enough, his son was in class and hadn't been in a car accident. Thieves are using AI to generate voices and demand wire transfers. Before you pay: 1) verify the information with official court records; 2) try reaching out to the person of the scam directly; 3) contact a lawyer to review the information. Bonds are typically paid through a bail bondsman or the clerk's office. Don't ever wire money in this situation.

05/02/2025
This clarifies the self defense law in Indiana.
03/16/2025

This clarifies the self defense law in Indiana.

The ruling offers new guidance on what constitutes allowable self-defense under Indiana law.

09/17/2024

🚨 SCAM ALERT 🚨

A phone scam threatening arrest for missing jury duty is making the rounds in central Indiana, including Hamilton County. The twist? Scammers are using names of Sheriff’s Office employees to make their calls seem legit.

Here's how it works: 📞 The scammer says you missed jury duty or owe taxes and claims a warrant is out for your arrest. 👮 They might even mention real courthouse employees or show a local number on your caller ID (which can be easily faked). 💳 To avoid "arrest," they demand payment via wire transfer or prepaid gift cards and put pressure on you to pay quickly.

Remember: 🚫 Hamilton County NEVER serves warrants over the phone. ☎️ If in doubt, hang up and call the official agency directly—don’t use a number they give you. ❌ Government agencies do NOT ask for payment via wire transfer or prepaid gift cards.

If you get one of these calls, report it to law enforcement ASAP. Contact Hamilton County Public Safety Communications at 317-773-1282 to get help or file a report.

Stay safe and informed!

Address

11 Municipal Drive, Suite 320-D
Fishers, IN
46038

Opening Hours

Monday 8am - 5pm
Tuesday 8am - 5pm
Wednesday 8am - 5pm
Thursday 8am - 5pm
Friday 8am - 5pm

Telephone

+13175882866

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when David M. Seiter, Attorney at Law posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share