10/26/2022
It is always a great honor to argue in the U.S. Court of Appeals and I had the opportunity to do so on October 20, 2022, in St. Paul, Minnesota. The case is a federal civil rights appeal. I am the first lawyer to present the case in this recording and the last to present on rebuttal.
The public sees case names and case numbers, but behind every case is a very human story. One of the tremendous benefits of 25 years of private practice is representing good people facing injustice and tough times. Championing their cases is why I became a lawyer. Kathie and Raymond Kvalvog are two of the fine people that I have had the great honor to represent. Kathie and Ray tragically lost their two sons in a car crash. They sent their sons off on a high school basketball trip that was determined to be a school event by a Clay County Jury in 2019 and never saw them again. That crash was highly preventable and when parents entrust the safety of their children to a school, answers are owed when tragedy occurs. As a parent, that hits home. I cannot fathom what they have gone through, but I remember that the first thing I felt as a parent was fear that there but for the grace of God go I. That is a frightening feeling to have and I just had to take the case. Last week, I had the honor of appearing in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit to argue their federal civil rights case. Our federal appeals courts are truly places of awe and this argument was no different. Ray and Kathy have fought relentlessly for answers and the truth in their case and although I never knew Zach or Connor Kvalvog, I am sure they would be proud of the fight for justice their parents have carried for them. Given the energy and zeal of their quest, hours of preparation went into putting together just the right legal arguments for the court and I let loose from the moment I started. I let the record speak for itself on the law, but this is just one of many examples of the real people with real and shattered lives that are behind every case name and case number. I hope that in the end, I did justice, and we prevail, but that will be up to the court.