18/03/2021
Here is the law on legal aid_in South Sudan.
Every accused person has a right to legal aid. In other words, any accused person before any court has a right to be defended by a lawyer appointed/provided by the state. In serious offenses, and if the accused is indigent to afford a lawyer, he/she has a right to be provided with an advocate by the state _s.184 of the Code of Criminal Procedure Act, 2008.
However, this right is not automatic. There are three criteria for granting it.
First, the accused has to satisfy the court of his/her indigency. In Awad Alla Al-Abass v Sudan Government (2011), Abdalmajed Al- Khadir ruled that "the right of an accused to be defended by a lawyer (legal aid) is contingent upon the accused being indigent and even then it depends upon his request." If this is partially satisfied, the state may require the accused to pay all or part of the cost.
Two, the accused has to apply to the Minister of Justice to provide him/her a lawyer. In Rahmetalla Adam Medani v Yagoup Musa Ibrahim and Sudan Government (2003), the constitutional court stated that "the right of the accused to be defended by a lawyer and his right to request the attorney general to have a lawyer appointed in case of indigence does not impose a mandatory obligation on the state but it is a right of the accused to demand legal aid."
Third, it must be in the interest of justice. Being indigent is one step. And submitting an application to the minister is another important step. But the applicant must show a failure to grant him legal aid would result in a miscarriage of justice. In other words, the applicant should demonstrate that providing legal aid also serves the interest of justice. This is tricky because a series of factors will be considered. One of the factors is the seriousness of the offense committed. In minor offenses, the state is unlikely to grant legal aid. Another factor is the public interest_ factors like whether it is fair and reasonable to provide legal aid in a particular case.
So, legal aid depends on the accused person's inability to afford a lawyer in a criminal case, the accused person submitting a request for a lawyer, and the accused person demonstrating it in the application that justice requires the state to provide legal aid.