15/12/2021
Observations on charity and what you can learn about charities by their actions.
A number of years ago, Dr. David Hubbard the former President of Fullers Seminary wrote an article called "The Ten Commandments for Development Officers."
Dr. Hubbard helped to build Fuller Seminary in Pasadena, California from an institution of some 300 students to one of over 3,000 students when he retired.
Here are his ten commandments for those working in the field of development, which is raising money for charity.
These ten commandments are very much linked to the Gospel of our Lord Jesus Christ. They also are very instructive for all of us who wish to support charity. They represent someone who followed our Lord Jesus in how he chose to pursue developing the institution he loved and worked for and how he wished the Gospel to be glorified in his actions in seeking financial support for Fuller Seminary.
Thou shalt decide who thou art in professional identity.
Thou shalt not take credit for major gifts that come thy way.
Thou shalt err on the side of understatement in the claims for the institution.
Thou shalt not scatter thy energies or turn thy focus from God, family, and mission.
Thou shalt honor the wishes of donors.
Thou shalt not play lawyer, tax accountant, nor realtor for thy donors.
Thou shalt not ape the lifestyle of thy major donors.
Thou shalt form strong ties with academic leaders.
Thou shalt use restraint in academic decisions.
Thou shalt not be shortsighted in the tension between current needs and long-term goals.
Most of these "commandments" are more of an institutional nature and for Dr. Hubbard, they were linked to an institution of higher education in teaching the Gospel of Jesus Christ, but in this short post I want to home in on one of these.
"Thou shalt not ape the lifestyle of thy major donors."
This is an important point and it is kind of an indicator that anyone can use to evaluate a charity to see if it is connected to your values.
For example, I once visited a very large church in a large American city and after visiting it wanted to learn more about it and its very large and extensive ministry.
So, I wrote to the head pastor and the head accountant.
I asked them if they had an audited financial statement that they made available to their donors.
This request was met with absolute shock and dismay.
How could I imagine asking such a question? What did I want to know? What would I use that information for?
Of course, if you see an audited financial statement, that document will include the salaries of the staff among other things. It might not be 100% itemized, but will get an idea of what people are making.
But what does it say about an organization (any organization) who will not quickly and openly reveal how they spend their donated funds?
In looking further at the particular organization, you got a kind of feeling that the pastor and those around him that he has surrounded himself with a very wealthy group of supporters.
Fundraising and seeking donations can have a sense of elitism attached to it because there is a strong tendency by those seeking donations to focus on those who have the most resources and wanting to be close to them for the long term. So says Lorne Miller, one of Canada's most famous fundraising consultants.
So, he may feel a need to try to "fit in" with that group of supporters.
This represents a major violation of Dr. Hubbard's commandment of not imitating or trying to maintain the lifestyle of those who support you.
Doing that may get you off your mission real quick.
In 2020, Americans donated $471.44 billion USD to charity. Most of those funds go to worthy charities. This is the picture of generosity.
But....
Just because someone works in the charitable sector does not mean that they are honest, does not mean that they use your donations wisely and does not mean that what they do is aligned to your values. Their lips may honor you, but their heart may be far from you as we have heard said.
Just watch an episode of American Greed and you will find plenty of examples of individuals, unfortunately, even in charities, whose priorities are focused on getting as much money as they can for themselves.
Be smart before you give your hard earned money to charity to be 100% certain that it reflects your values and that it is not being used to finance someone's lifestyles of the rich and famous dream.
As always, if you every have any questions, feel free to message me.