19/07/2026
Breaking News in Australia-Alleged DV victim labelled 'difficult witness', family court permanently removes children
A confronting ABC investigation has highlighted serious questions about how Australia's family court system handles cases involving allegations of domestic violence and child abuse.
The story follows a mother who lost custody of her two children despite alleging years of abuse by her former partner. The court found there was insufficient evidence to support those allegations, but in an extraordinary twist, the father—who had been awarded sole custody—returned the children to their mother, saying the outcome was not what he wanted and was not in the children's best interests.
The investigation also examines new research suggesting family courts may not be well equipped to assess complex family violence and child sexual abuse allegations. Researchers argue that trauma can affect how victims present in court and are calling for reforms to improve understanding of coercive control, abuse and grooming.
It's a powerful reminder of how difficult and complex these cases can be—and why many experts believe the system needs reform to better protect children and families.
The Family Court granted John full custody of his kids, but he returned them to their mother, saying the judge got it wrong.