06/24/2019
TracFone’s UNLIMITED CARRYOVER is not a mark
TracFone had sought a registration for UNLIMITED CARRYOVER to identify its telecommunication services. The Examining Attorney refused registration on the basis that UNLIMITED CARRYOVER fails to function as a service mark for its services. In a precedential decision, the TTAB agreed, focusing particularly on the evidence of use provided by TracFone. The Board determined that the phrase was set in the midst of other clearly informational manner and would not designate the source of TracFone’s services.
The Board rejected TracFone’s arguments that the “mark” had been in use for almost a decade and that registrations for ROLLOVER DATA and ROLLOVER MINUTES justified registration of UNLIMITED CARRYOVER.
LESSON - IMHO, the way TracFone uses UNLIMITED CARRYOVER doomed the application from the beginning. More prominent use may have helped secure a registration.