26/05/2021
HOW TO PROVE ROOT OF TITLE UNDER TRADITIONAL HISTORY.
MR. ODONMA DANIEL V. PASTOR GODFREY OCHECHEMA ADOLE
(2019) LCN/13919(CA)
It is trite that a party seeking for a declaration of title to land who relies on traditional history as proof of his root of title, must plead same sufficiently. That is to say, he must demonstrate in his pleading the original founder of the land, how he founded the land, and the particulars of the intervening owners through whom he claims. Where a party has not given sufficient information in his pleadings as regards the origin or ownership of the land and the line of succession to himself, he has just laid the foundation for the failure of his claim. In Ezeokonkwo V Okeke (2002) LPELR-1211(SC) 17-18, the Supreme Court, per Iguh, JSC held:
It cannot be over-emphasised that it is not sufficient for a party who relies for proof of title to land on traditional history to merely plead that he, and before him, his predecessors in title had owned and possessed the land from time beyond human memory. He must also plead and prove:- (i) who founded the land, (ii) how the land was founded and (iii) particulars of the intervening owners through whom he claims.?
Therefore, a party who hinges his claim of declaration of title to land on traditional history must establish how his ancestor, the original owner, acquired the land, i.e. whether by settlement, conquest or grant. A claim predicated on traditional history or evidence must be proved by any of the recognized methods, and the traditional history adduced must be cogent, un-contradicted evidence that must also be conclusive, if the party is to succeed. Thus, a plaintiff who relies on traditional history as his proof of title must aver in his statement of claim/counter-claim seriatim the genealogical tree or line of succession of the family from the cradle of its founding fathers to him and he must also lead admissible evidence in vindication or proof of the statement of claim/counter-claim. Unless he performs these twin procedural functions, his action is bound to fail.
PER JUMMAI HANNATU SANKEY, J.C.A.