08/17/2025
The Stages of a Criminal Case in Canada
As a criminal defence lawyer in Montreal, I know that an arrest is one of the most stressful and destabilizing experiences a person can go through. In just a few minutes, you may find yourself handcuffed, deprived of liberty, and subjected to initial police questioning. Every decision made at this stage can have lasting consequences for your work, your family, and even your freedom.
With more than twenty years of defending clients in Quebec, I have seen how the right approach in the first hours after an arrest can completely change the outcome of a case. This article explains what happens after an arrest, what rights you have at each stage, and how to avoid common mistakes that could harm your defence.
1. Your Rights at the Time of Arrest
From the moment of arrest, the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees you certain protections. The police must:
clearly explain the reason for your arrest;
inform you of your right to remain silent;
give you the opportunity to immediately contact a lawyer.
Why are these rights so important?
In my experience, most mistakes happen in the very first hours after an arrest. In shock, many people want to explain themselves, thinking it will help their case. Unfortunately, everything you say can—and will—be used against you. Even innocent explanations can be misinterpreted.
Lawyer’s advice: politely tell the police that you wish to remain silent and speak to a lawyer. Do not try to justify yourself or answer questions until you have consulted with legal counsel.
From my practice — when silence saved the case
A client was recently arrested in Montreal for alleged shoplifting. In shock, she wanted to “clear up the misunderstanding” with the police. I firmly advised her to remain silent. Later, upon reviewing the evidence, it became clear that the Crown’s case was very weak. Because she made no statements, we secured a complete withdrawal of the charges before trial. Had she tried to explain herself on the spot, her words could have been twisted and used against her.
2. Police Detention or Release
After an arrest, the police decide whether to release you or hold you until a bail hearing. The decision depends on the seriousness of the charges, your criminal record, and the perceived risk of flight or danger to the public.
Possible outcomes:
Release with a promise to appear
You sign a document promising to appear in court on a set date.
Failure to appear results in additional charges.
Release with conditions
Possible conditions:
no contact with certain people or places;
compliance with a curfew;
abstaining from alcohol or drugs.
Breaching conditions is a separate criminal offence.
Detention until a bail hearing
If the police refuse release, they must bring you before a judge or justice of the peace within 24 hours.
From my practice — the power of a well-prepared release plan
I defended a young man accused of assault. The Crown wanted to keep him in custody until trial. We quickly prepared a detailed plan, including a reliable surety and strict conditions. The court agreed to his release, allowing him to keep working and supporting his family while we prepared his defence.
3. The Bail Hearing
If the police do not release you, a bail hearing — also called a “show cause hearing” — must take place within 24 hours of the arrest.
How it works:
The Crown prosecutor explains why you should remain in custody.
Your lawyer must show that you can be released safely, often by proposing strict conditions or a surety.
The court considers:
Will you return to court?
Do you pose a risk to public safety?
Would your release undermine public confidence in the justice system?
Why preparation is crucial
I have seen clients appear at bail hearings without a lawyer and end up detained for months. A poorly prepared hearing can ruin lives: job loss, broken relationships, and immense pressure to plead guilty just to get out.
Lawyer’s advice: a bail hearing is not a formality. It is often your best chance to be released during the legal process.
4. Official Charges and the First Court Appearance
After an arrest, the Crown prosecutor reviews the police evidence and decides whether to lay formal charges. If charges are filed, you will be given a date for your first court appearance.
What to expect:
The charges are read in court.
Your lawyer requests disclosure: all evidence (police reports, witness statements, videos, expert reports).
You may enter a plea or request more time to review the evidence.
The importance of disclosure
Early access to disclosure allows us to assess the strength of the Crown’s case. Errors or weak evidence can lead to reduced charges, alternative measures, or even a full withdrawal.
From my practice — when disclosure changed everything
A client was charged with assault. At the first appearance, we obtained disclosure and identified contradictions in witness statements. By presenting these inconsistencies to the Crown, we secured a withdrawal of all charges before the case went to trial.
Tip: do not plead guilty at the first appearance just to “get it over with.” You may be giving up valid defences.
5. Building Your Defence
Once charges are laid, the case progresses toward negotiation, settlement, or trial. Early and thorough defence work is essential.
What we do for our clients:
Evidence analysis: we review procedural errors, highlight inconsistencies, and identify weaknesses in the Crown’s case.
Negotiation with the Crown: many cases are resolved through reduced charges or alternatives, such as conditional discharges or diversion programs.
Trial preparation: we prepare witnesses, gather expert reports, and build a solid cross-examination strategy.
From my practice — avoiding a criminal record
A client accused of minor drug possession contacted me immediately after his arrest. We demonstrated the low seriousness of the offence and his lack of prior record. I negotiated a conditional discharge, sparing him a criminal record, protecting his job, and preserving his ability to travel.
Frequently Asked Questions about Criminal Charges in Quebec
Will I go to jail?
Not necessarily. Many people are released after arrest — either by the police or at the bail hearing (within 24 hours). Detention depends on:
the seriousness of the charges;
your criminal record;
the Crown’s assessment of risk.
Should I talk to the police?
Absolutely not. You have the fundamental right to remain silent and consult with a lawyer before answering any questions. This right applies from the moment of arrest and throughout the investigation.
Remember: questioning is designed to gather evidence, not to “clear your name.” Even casual comments can be taken out of context and used against you in court.
Lawyer’s advice: calmly say, “I wish to remain silent and speak to my lawyer,” and stop talking. This is not an admission of guilt; it is the best way to protect your rights.
How long will the process take?
It depends on the complexity of the case and whether it goes to trial:
simple cases (weak evidence or quick resolution) can be resolved in a few months;
contested cases (multiple witnesses or serious charges) can take a year or more.
Delays can occur if the Crown is slow to provide disclosure or if the courts are overloaded.
Can I work or travel during the process?
That depends on your release conditions. They may restrict:
travel outside the city, province, or country;
certain types of work related to the alleged offence;
contact with people involved, even family members.
If conditions are too restrictive, your lawyer can request modifications. I have secured relaxations that allowed clients to work, study, or visit family abroad while their cases were ongoing.
What happens if I violate my conditions?
Any violation — even accidental — is a separate criminal offence in Quebec. You risk being re-arrested and facing new charges. It is therefore crucial to fully understand your conditions and seek clarification from your lawyer.
Can I avoid a criminal record?
In many cases, yes. Diversion programs, conditional discharges, or negotiated settlements can prevent a criminal record. Everything depends on the charges, your history, and the strength of the evidence.
From my practice
I have negotiated conditional discharges even in cases that seemed hopeless. Acting early and presenting the right evidence makes all the difference.
Why You Should Consult a Lawyer Right Away
Too often I meet people who waited before seeking legal advice and are now facing problems that could have been avoided:
unfair release conditions disrupting family and work;
missed deadlines limiting defence options;
convictions that could have been prevented.
By consulting a lawyer immediately after arrest, you:
understand your rights and options from the very beginning;
avoid harmful mistakes;
have a tailored strategy to resolve your case effectively.
Your best defence begins the moment you call a lawyer. Acting quickly gives you the advantage of preparation and control.
Conclusion: Consult a Criminal Lawyer in Montreal Today
If you or a loved one has been arrested in Quebec, you are not alone against the justice system. Our team at Guzun & Associés has been defending clients in criminal matters for more than twenty years. We understand what is at stake and fight for the best possible outcome.
Book your consultation today:
Phone: +1 (514) 576-7414
Email: [email protected]
Meeting: at our Old Montreal office or online.
A single free orientation call can provide you with the clarity and guidance needed to regain control of your situation and protect your future.
We invite you to visit our website www.avocatguzun.com, where you will find a wealth of useful information and can also book your consultation online.