18/04/2026
The case of the hospital food menu will
In this recent case, the Supreme Court of NSW found that handwritten notations on a hospital food menu constituted the deceased’s last will.
In 2007, the deceased did a will giving the whole of his estate (worth $500,000) to his then de facto partner.
In 2024, the deceased, while a patient at Nepean Hospital, made notes on a hospital food menu giving the whole of his estate to a different person, a friend of 55 years. The deceased signed the document, but it was not witnessed and therefore did not comply with the formal requirements of a will. Three days later, the deceased contacted a lawyer to have his wishes formalised but refused to pay more than $100 for a new will. At the time, the lawyer told him, “you’re living in the 70s”. The document was never witnessed.
After the deceased’s death, the deceased’s quasi stepdaughter propounded the 2007 Will. She also brought a family provision claim on the basis that she was a single mother, with two dependent children, a net worth of $44,000, and unable to work without medical clearance.
The friend propounded the hospital food menu will.
The Court found that it was satisfied that the deceased intended for the hospital food menu document to constitute his last will. The estate would flow to the friend. However, the Court was also satisfied that the quasi stepdaughter’s family provision claim was successful and granted her provision of $200,000.
Without intending any disrespect to the deceased, this is a great example of where being cheap costs you more in the long run.